Daily quiz

New York Mutuals Strikeouts Leaders

Career totals with the New York Mutuals and the best single seasons in club history. Records run through the 2025 season.

New York Mutuals records →

Bobby Mathews holds the New York Mutuals career record with 255 strikeouts. The single-season record is 101, by Bobby Mathews in 1874.

ERA W SO SV WHIP IP K/9 BB/9 K/BB SHO CG GS G L BB W-L%

All-time New York Mutuals leaders

Career totals with the club
# Player With the club SO G
1 Bobby Mathews Bobby Mathews 1873–1875 255 187
2 Candy Cummings Candy Cummings 1872 45 55
3 Rynie Wolters Rynie Wolters 1871 22 32
4 Count Gedney Count Gedney 1875 2 2
5 Phonney Martin Phonney Martin 1873 1 6
5 John McMullin John McMullin 1872 1 3

Single-season New York Mutuals records

Best seasons in club history
# Player Season SO G
1 Bobby Mathews Bobby Mathews 1874 101 65
2 Bobby Mathews Bobby Mathews 1873 79 52
3 Bobby Mathews Bobby Mathews 1875 75 70
4 Candy Cummings Candy Cummings 1872 45 55
5 Rynie Wolters Rynie Wolters 1871 22 32
6 Count Gedney Count Gedney 1875 2 2
7 Phonney Martin Phonney Martin 1873 1 6
7 John McMullin John McMullin 1872 1 3