This website and the domain leagueleaders.com are for sale. See the details →
Daily quiz

New York Mutuals Hits Leaders

Career totals with the New York Mutuals and the best single seasons in club history. Records run through the 2025 season.

Joe Start holds the New York Mutuals career record with 73 hits. The single-season record is 73, by Joe Start in 1876.

AVG HR RBI H R SB OPS OBP SLG 2B 3B XBH TB BB SO PA AB G

All-time New York Mutuals leaders

Career totals with the club
# Player With the club H G
1 Joe Start Joe Start 1876 73 56
2 Jimmy Hallinan 1876 67 54
3 Jim Holdsworth 1876 64 52
4 Bill Craver Bill Craver 1876 55 56
5 Fred Treacey Fred Treacey 1876 54 57
6 Eddie Booth 1876 49 57
7 Nat Hicks Nat Hicks 1876 44 45
8 Bobby Mathews Bobby Mathews 1876 40 56
9 Al Nichols 1876 38 57
10 George Bechtel George Bechtel 1876 3 2
10 John Hayes 1876 3 5
12 Robert Maloney 1876 2 2
13 John Hatfield John Hatfield 1876 1 1
13 Jim Shanley 1876 1 2

Single-season New York Mutuals records

Best seasons in club history